My experience with plastic props supplied with kits is that they frequently seem to be of very poor design. If you study them closely you will frequently see thay have almost zero pitch at the blade tip. I have experienced this with two different kit manufacturers. My last one went forwards very slowly but simply would not go astern at all. Exactly the same as another one I built a few years ago!
It isn’t the material that is the problem, it is the design, all driven by getting the cost as low as possible. Stick a Prop Shop prop on and the performance will be transformed!