This is the trouble with hoarding odd things especially motors….is that you dont know what spec they are. I have a few odd small motors and odds are I will never use them!!
I always advocate overpowering model boats, on the basis that if you dont have enough power for emergencies, you can be severely stuffed (swans chasing geese for instance, dont look for models when landing). There is no such thing as overpowering a model, its what speed controllers are for.
For a sub, more power definately. In the can size for 200 series motors there are a good assortment, from bog standard MFA 280, to Graupner speed 280 race ones, or JUST stightly larger their speed 300. Mostly Iike to ensure I can swap motors easily in my boats and so am able to fit different types according to trials or later considerations (changing battery types or voltages),
Ashley