working icebreaker

working icebreaker

Home Forums Scratch build working icebreaker

  • This topic is empty.
Viewing 24 posts - 1 through 24 (of 24 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #17471
    ashley needham
    Participant
      @ashleyneedham69188

      I am keen to build a WORKING icebreaker after the last lot of ice on the pond. Every year we have ice and everyone and his dog says "ooh, i wish i had an icebreaker"   well. so be it. An instant build, no detail—that can come later, one morning max…ok perhaps a days worth….. I had my eye on the navy`s River class patrol boats for the hull….ie that curious chopped front end. This would give me the big slope needed at the front to ride up on the ice, and enable ALL the sides of the hull to be straight. I am contemplating using a plank for the base and hardboard or 4mm ply for the sides (as its what i have in the shed and is cheap) and weight is not an object. Size,,,ooo er   … 8 inches wide by about 32 long seems good to me. Sides 5 inches deep keel to bulwarks, or even a bit more, enabling a goodly amount of weight to be packed in there. The front would have a thin steel strip on it to stop the relativly soft bow pointy bit getting damaged and also focus the weight, with a tang at the bottom to stop the ship riding up and beaching itself on the ice. Propulsion is the sticky bit. Needs a good shove capability.. i have a 2.5;1 geared 540 wot i am thinking of ,driving a 55mm 3 blade plastic prop (as its all in my spares box)..but will this be enough?  and some sort of rudder protection is required (from last weeks foray by HMS Jersye in  the ice flow) … comments please…..? Ashley

      #17478
      Bob Abell 2
      Participant
        @bobabell2

        That sounds OK to me Ashley!………..The Ice Man cometh?

        Looking forward to seeing in action…………..I think it needs to be heavy?

        That would be a laugh………….. if it rode up onto the ice ……………and kept going!!!!

        Bob

        #17483
        ashley needham
        Participant
          @ashleyneedham69188

          Bob. Yup, heavy is the word. A conventional model will not work as there is not enough weight in the bows for crushing ice. Hence my boat will be very deep, deeper than looks right, in order to get this factor in. It sounds a bit pathetic but i cant see it crushing more that the 1/4 inch of ice we had last Sunday…however thats about as thick as I have seen it on the pond in some years !

          A story was related at the pond regarding an incident  last year when there was ice about….there was a small section of pond un-iced, but with floes in it, and there were a lot of ducks in the water, or on the ice… The man in question, Dave, had his tug, a lightweight type, and was going around the ducks "as there was clear water in between the ducks and floes" quote, and as he got near one duck, it appears the duck was actually standing on an underwater sheet of ice, jumped off as the tug came near, and the ice rose to the surface neatly dry docking Daves tug ! to the merriment of all, one assumes. Ashley

          #17487
          Paul T
          Participant
            @pault84577

            Morning all

            The longer you think about this subject the more complex it becomes.

            Do you build a scale model of a real icebreaker and design in the required power and weight or do you build a radical small boat (600mm long) intended to break the ice i.e. with powered cutters or mechanical hammers?

            How about an amphibian with big, wide tyres that will chew up the thinner ice but uses its weight to break through the thicker ice as it rides up onto the surface.

            A knotty problem

            Paul

            #17497
            ashley needham
            Participant
              @ashleyneedham69188

              Chaps. More thought on this subject.

              (from front to rear).

              Double chine hull, as per previous, with a thin steel sheath on the pointy bit..

              No step at the bottom to prevent riding up, because…..

              Although the bottom will be flat, i will have a thin, again, steel, strip running along the centreline., This is because when the Jersey nearly got beached on the ice from running up, the weight was spread over the entire hull, it being fairly round,,,, so.. if there was just a very thin strip on the bottom, when the boat rode up on the ice.. the entire weight would be concentrated on this strip, hopefully resulting in a break…?

              Again, from watching the jersy almost beach on an ice shelf……the propeller needs to be well below the keel, so it is always in the water to push or pull, as needs must, when or if the boat beaches.

              Needs rudder protection when going astern to prevent damage from hitting rearward floes.

              A hard point for a ring to tie a safety line to the boat may be a good idea…..      Ashley

              #17498
              ashley needham
              Participant
                @ashleyneedham69188

                Oh, and the ballast… this needs to be split front and rear, as far front as poss, so that the maximum weight can be bought to bear when sliding the bows up the ice…. and not parcelled around like wot i normally do.    A

                #17508
                Bob Abell 2
                Participant
                  @bobabell2

                  It`s going to be a "Hard day`s night"………………….built in a day?

                  Seriously though…………..it`s a novel idea and should be great fun breaking through the ice

                  Pictures please?

                  Bob

                  PS……………………………………………………………… Is it finished yet?

                  #17520
                  ashley needham
                  Participant
                    @ashleyneedham69188

                    Well, if it was summer I would build it in a day, but the glue takes a whole day to dry in this weather. I have been chopping wood this afternoon. Had a nice big plank for the base, hardboard for sides,,,may use 4mm ply for the front. Dont expect a work of art. This is going to be, lets say, basic. Lets face it, if it dont work, I dont want have spent loads of time on it, especially as it will get used only about twice a year .  It should look ok once daubed with red paint and a white box superstructure. Mind you, dont expect much ice again soon !! I have some aluminium angle to screw under the boat for an ice breaking ridge..just found it on the garage roof.

                    I wonder if there would be a way to measure the ice breaking potential??   Ashley

                    #17784
                    ashley needham
                    Participant
                      @ashleyneedham69188

                      Bah humbug. It looks like it may well be bitter cold, and more importantly… ICY over the weekend and the icebreaker is progressing very slowly, mainly due to a major cut`n`shut job on the front as I realised the front angle was not shallow enough, and the freezing cold in my shed. Predictably the bow is a few degrees adrift of being central now, but i am not that bothered as its only a bash boat. There is the steel front to it, not as sharp as I envisaged but i am not sure that this matters too much. I forsee a spate of overtime painting and fitting remote control gear to get the thing in the water by Sunday even if the deck isnt in place !!!! It weighs a ton as it is without any batteries etc, so thats looking good, I will try to post some pictures. If I get it finished, or at least mobile, by Sunday I may take the Titanic out for a larf as well….Ashley

                      #17788
                      Paul T
                      Participant
                        @pault84577

                        My money is on the Iceberg (that ruined the film for me as I never expected the ship to hit anything)

                        #17823
                        ashley needham
                        Participant
                          @ashleyneedham69188

                          The bath test..   I plopped the boat in the bath and the water reached barely one inch up from the bottom, I loaded  2x 12v 7Ahr batteries, 4x 6v 4.5Ahr batteries….and the water only reached barely on the halfway mark betwixt top`n`bottom on the hull sides!!!!!.  how heavy???  I have a feeling my geared motor may be inadequate, never mind, the nose of the boat was attempting to push its way up the end of the bath when 12v was applied to the motor.

                          Paul…..its ridiculous, fancy making a disaster movie about a ship hitting an iceberg!!! how unlikely is that? how could a big ship like that POSSIBLY miss an iceberg, Its daft.       Ashley

                          #17830
                          Bob Abell 2
                          Participant
                            @bobabell2

                            What about a Dumb Ice Breaker?…………….No, not you Ashley!……………..But a heavy craft that could be pushed in front of a powerful tugboat!

                            Could be great fun?…………………In fact, you could convert your latest masterpiece and fill it full of bricks and rubble for ballast?

                            Any good?

                            Bob the Inventor

                            #17837
                            ashley needham
                            Participant
                              @ashleyneedham69188

                              Bob your idea has….er, merit, but I think would become uncontrollable without being firmly tied to said tug in order that it stays infront of said tug and dont divert to the side. So saying, its no good to me as i dont have a tug, powerful or otherwise!!!    I suppose you could fit beams projecting rearwards so as to keep tug and dumb in  line, but you would still need a tow rope to pull it off the ice. Keep the ideas coming, its good to think outside the box.

                              However the subject of pitch on a prop interests me. In the aircraft world, a fine pitch prop has more thrust (i presume for a given enging size/power) so is better for ,say, take-off, but a pitchier prop allows you to,go faster. Does this hold true on boat props???? My icebreaker (now covered in red paint) could do with low speed grunt, as speed will not be of much use.  Ashley

                              #17847
                              Bob Abell 2
                              Participant
                                @bobabell2

                                http://www.modelboats.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/sites/5/images/member_albums/2459/lake-500.jpg

                                Where`s Ashley when you Need`ham?

                                Our ice is 1 inch thin at Etherow!……………Methinks you`ll have a job on here!

                                Bob

                                #17848
                                ashley needham
                                Participant
                                  @ashleyneedham69188

                                  Hmmmm…. I may need to up-size!!!     Ashley

                                  #17853
                                  ashley needham
                                  Participant
                                    @ashleyneedham69188

                                    http://www.modelboats.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/sites/5/images/member_albums/2861/DSCF0767.JPG

                                    http://www.modelboats.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/sites/5/images/member_albums/2861/DSCF0768.JPG

                                    http://www.modelboats.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/sites/5/images/member_albums/2861/DSCF0769.JPG

                                    well well, a good 1/2″ of ice and predictably utter failiure! even lifting the boat up on the ice failed to break it !!!! i didnt have enough weight for todays ice thats for sure, even with six batteries in and two large lumps of lead. I didnt have enough thrust to get it up on the ice properly, assuming it was a bit thinner, and also the boat needed to have been another foot longer so that it didnt side off sideways too much, it also would have allowed more hull to get up on the ice and thus more weight. The aluminium ridge under the hull front worked a treat tho` when “assisted” by a helping hand. I am afraid i will consign the hull to the bin of eternity. The main problem is not having ice the correct thickness, and theres not much you can do about that is there? Ashley the thwarted.

                                    #17854
                                    Bob Abell 2
                                    Participant
                                      @bobabell2

                                      A good try Ashley the Thwarted…………….but you were beaten by Mother Nature!

                                      Perhaps a 10 lb weight on a rope would have done the trick and your craft could just have pushed the ice to one side?

                                      "Bob I told you so!"

                                      #17859
                                      ashley needham
                                      Participant
                                        @ashleyneedham69188

                                        No need to tell me so, I knew it from the  start…but you have to try, eh???

                                        Disclaimer for all those who think its foolish to led the lad stand on ice over 6 feet of water….wellllll, yes but I know its only 10 inches deep there so i let him out. He didnt go any further.

                                        #17866
                                        Paul T
                                        Participant
                                          @pault84577

                                          Hi Ashley

                                          Nice disclaimer but I note from the photo that just in case something went wrong you took the extra precaution of loading the poor boy with stones………a perfect choice if the ice broke as the evidence would be at the bottom of the lake.

                                          Happy new year Ashley

                                          #17883
                                          ashley needham
                                          Participant
                                            @ashleyneedham69188

                                            Sorry Paul, its his plum duff,not a stone…… Ashley

                                            (although the way the missus makes `em…..)

                                            happy new year to u 2.   Speaking of u boats….your M1……>?????

                                            #17885
                                            Paul T
                                            Participant
                                              @pault84577

                                              Morning Ashley

                                              Now your in real trouble with the missus…..plum duff…….oh dear!

                                              The M1 is still very much in the thinking stage as I have no experience of subs and want to fully understand all of the factors involved before I start to build. I have started the basic drawings but thats as far as I have got on this project, you know what it is like having an idea banging around in your head where one solved problem raises another.

                                              I am busy with the barrel back for the design competition and still have the 6ft TID to complete and besides its freezing cold in the workshop as unlike Uncle Bob I don’t have heating…… or carpets……. or a tea machine.

                                              Take care on the roads today.

                                              Paul

                                              #17887
                                              neil hp
                                              Participant
                                                @neilhp

                                                I now do believe this must be a real probability as a project for you, and the sooner you build one Ashley, the better.

                                                Then you could lease it out.

                                                I drove past Fleetwood’s lakes this morning and the sea water lakes were frozen solid.

                                                It takes a lot  to freeze salt water.

                                                Now! who said the arctic was thawing out…………….…………………give me one good reason to believe them, lol

                                                #6524
                                                ashley needham
                                                Participant
                                                  @ashleyneedham69188
                                                  #26642
                                                  HvyCGN-9
                                                  Participant
                                                    @hvycgn-9
                                                    there is a really nice 1/100 scale Icebreaker on the RCGroups site ‘Polar 8 project’ She has even broken real ice (and damaged some props!!)
                                                     
                                                    Bruce
                                                  Viewing 24 posts - 1 through 24 (of 24 total)
                                                  • Please log in to reply to this topic. Registering is free and easy using the links on the menu at the top of this page.

                                                  Code of conduct | Forum Help/FAQs

                                                  Latest Replies

                                                  Home Forums Scratch build Topics

                                                  Viewing 25 topics - 1 through 25 (of 25 total)
                                                  Viewing 25 topics - 1 through 25 (of 25 total)

                                                  View full reply list.