Everyone seems to be impressed with brushless motors, but of course you would be if you took out a brushed motor of 50 Watts and replaced with a smaller motor at 150 Watts.
From what have seen, people do not replace motors with an equivalent power brushless motor, they upgrade by some margin.
We use brushless at the pond for light fast craft, where weight and size is an issue. In point of fact a powerfull motor will not develop that power unless loaded properly, and despite being fitted with 160 watt brushless, our Tups are probably only developing 80 Watts due to the small props. This is obviously beneficial in that the current consumption is kept Down and this is probably what’s happening on your hydro.
Ashley