Which motor?

Advert

Which motor?

Home Forums Beginners Which motor?

  • This topic is empty.
Viewing 25 posts - 1 through 25 (of 41 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #87446
    Joe Beckett
    Participant
      @joebeckett71895

      Hi All,

      Like a number of posters here, I took up model boating again because of the lockdown. I have previously built a Robbe Atlantis that I recently fully restored. I have now just ordered a Lesro Fairey Huntsman 47" model and I am intending to fit it out as close to the original boat and therefore have entered the minefield world of which motor/s to use? I really would like to go brushless and LiPo and also have twin engines. I've researched kv's,T's, can sizes and Watts, so have an idea of what I want but am I heading in the right direction? I would like the finished boat to be able to get up on the plane quickly and have a decent turn of speed but I don't want to break any records! Any advice welcome. Thanks

      Advert
      #2917
      Joe Beckett
      Participant
        @joebeckett71895

        New to r/c electronics, need advice

        #87450
        Chris Fellows
        Participant
          @chrisfellows72943

          Hi and welcome Joe

          Brushless and LiPos definitely. Thoughts tend to be that twin motor setups aren't much quicker if anything than single so the motor sizes will be pretty much the same.

          Initial thoughts would be something like a pair of Overlander 5045/10 720kV which on 4S LiPo would rev at 10600.

          Is this around what you're thinking of?

          Chris

          #87453
          Joe Beckett
          Participant
            @joebeckett71895

            Hi Chris, Thanks for the reply. That's kind of what I am thinking of, although your suggestion may be a little under-powered? That said, I don't know the weight of the finished model yet, so this all might be a bit premature. The model is quite large and I believe largely made of ply so by the time it is all fitted out, I am guessing it might weigh quite a bit. If anyone who owns one knows the all-up weight, that would be really useful. I am looking at a pair of Turnigy AquaStar 4084-1050KV Water Cooled Brushless Motor, although I have no particular experience of this motor, it does have built in cooling and an inrunner is (IMO) easier to fit? Am I right in thinking generally speaking, an outrunner offers a bit more torque and is 'slower' spinning than an inrunner? As I said, it's a minefield!

            #87457
            ashley needham
            Participant
              @ashleyneedham69188

              Joe. GENERALLY speaking, in-runners seem to be in the higher revving bracket, but outrunners vary from 40Kv to 10,000Kv (for ducted fan use).

              Accepted wisdom here is that a motor matched to the hull/prop may well get warm, but should not necessarily require water cooling. That said, interior ventilation is recommended to stop heat build up.

              Sorry, would not like to hazard a guess as to what you might fit. However, fitting a more common size pays dividends if/when you want to swap them out.

              DM is the Fairey god and he will lay down chapter and verse as to what you should fit….

              Ashley

              #87461
              Dave Milbourn
              Participant
                @davemilbourn48782

                DM is the Fairey god and he will lay down chapter and verse as to what you should fit….

                A LESRO Huntsman 31? Never heard of it.

                If it's anything like the one from SLEC then I would fit just one motor anyway – one of these G60 outrunner and run it on a 5S or 6S LiPo pack. Other manufacturers' similar products may well be available.

                Twin motors = 2 x the expense and 2 x the potential trouble. You won't know the difference once it's in the water, anyway.

                The Fairey God has spoken smile d

                DM

                #87463
                ashley needham
                Participant
                  @ashleyneedham69188

                  I bow before the master.

                  Ashley

                  Edited By ashley needham on 02/05/2020 18:09:06

                  #87464
                  Ray Wood 3
                  Participant
                    @raywood3

                    The Master has spoken 😀

                    #87465
                    Joe Beckett
                    Participant
                      @joebeckett71895

                      Thanks All, I am honoured to be amongst such distinguished company!😉. Thanks for all the responses, as they say knowledge is power! I may be putting my head above the parapet here but……DM, is a 500kv motor going to get this on the plane and give a decent turn of speed? I believe it is the SLEC model as you suggest,I bought it from Lesro Models in Poole! Do you happen to know how much the model weighs? Call me………but I really would like to fit twin engines so would really appreciate advice on that set up? Maybe I should wait until the model arrives and go from there?! Ohh the excitement!!! Sounds like I found the right forum anyway! Thanks again.

                      #87469
                      Dave Milbourn
                      Participant
                        @davemilbourn48782

                        Joe

                        I designed the original Huntsman 31 @ 1/8 scale in 1972 for Model Avionics, which became Balsacraft International Ltd t/a Precedent Kits. They subsequently became SLEC who now manufacture a range of model boats, some of which were designed a long time ago by Les Rowell and marketed at that time as Lesro Models. After Les's death these were made by a company called Vintage Model Boat Co, which was then sold to SLEC. Are you with me so far?

                        The original H31 1/8 had a glowplug motor which churned out around 1.2BHP. With a 5S LiPo the G60 should produce 9250 RPM and approx the same power. If you increase that to a 6S pack then the power will comfortably exceed that of the original HP 61F R/C motor. Use a 7S LiPo and it will be ballistic.

                        The model might possibly weigh a little more with LiPo batteries as opposed to a tank full of glow-fuel, but the performance should be the same if not better. I don't recall weighing the original model but it had enough poke to tow a rowing boat around Danson Park Lake in Sidcup with the late and much-missed John Rudd standing in the bow with the Tx! On that particular occasion I declined an offer of marriage from a woman passer-by with a pram…..

                        There's no escaping from nutters at a boating lake.

                        My advice on fitting twin motors is simple – you're on your own.

                        Dave M

                         

                        Edited By Dave Milbourn on 02/05/2020 19:31:33

                        #87471
                        Chris Fellows
                        Participant
                          @chrisfellows72943

                          Hi again

                          As Ashley says, inrunners are generally high revving motors and for boat use more suited to very high performance and race craft. With something of the size, weight and design of many of the Fairey Marine model boats what you need is a fairly torquey motor to get it moving and then with sufficient revs to give it a good top speed.

                          Outrunners are more torquey so one decision made and you need one with quite a large diameter to give the power required. I generally recommend a motor around 900 to 1100 kV as a good compromise but as motor diameters get bigger the kV tend to get smaller hence why I suggested the 720kV motors. The motor DM suggested is even lower which is why he's suggested running on a 5S or 6S LiPo pack to increase the revs and give the performance required. You pays yer money and makes your choice.

                          I doubt that my suggestion will be underpowered as brushless motors are very powerful for their size, probably the opposite! And you can always increase the volts!

                          I have one of the big Huntsman, when the kit was produced by Precedent and I'll see how much it weighs. I know it's bloomin' heavy!

                          Chris

                          Edit: Dave posted whilst I was rambling so has given you more info.

                           

                          Edited By Chris Fellows on 02/05/2020 19:52:43

                          #87472
                          Joe Beckett
                          Participant
                            @joebeckett71895

                            But…..was the baby yours?😁. Thanks again for the (very informative and useful info. I'm going to start the build and go from there. If I did go twin, will I actually be ex-communicated, or can I still rely on the help from my new-found friends?!!! Have a good weekend and stay safe.😷

                            #87473
                            Chris Fellows
                            Participant
                              @chrisfellows72943

                              There has been a number of builds using twin motors. There is one on Model Boat Mayhem at the moment but it is for the smaller 34" version and he's using brushed motors so can't really interpolate from that.

                              Chris

                              #87474
                              Joe Beckett
                              Participant
                                @joebeckett71895

                                Thanks Chris,. As always, you start with an idea and then get expert help from guys like you lot. It's really useful to have a forum like this to bounce ideas off! Hasta la vista, I'll be back!😀

                                #87476
                                Paul T
                                Participant
                                  @pault84577

                                  Joe

                                  Imagine putting a V8 in a Mini and you will get the general idea.

                                  #87485
                                  Dave Milbourn
                                  Participant
                                    @davemilbourn48782

                                    But…..was the baby yours?

                                    Fortunately not – I'd never seen the b****y woman before and certainly not since. I don't have an enviable record as a Dad but that's another story for another time. I'm better at making Faireys!

                                    Dave M

                                    #87496
                                    Chris Fellows
                                    Participant
                                      @chrisfellows72943

                                      Joe

                                      And I forgot that a chap called UKMike is building the same kit on Mayhem in the Pleasure Boats etc. section in a thread called Fairey Huntsman Aft Cabin Becomes a Sports Fisherman. As the name suggests he is making some modifications to the build which includes fitting 2 No. 1kW motors. He is a very meticulous builder and made a lovely job of a Riva. I don't know how he has arrived at the power required and what motors he is proposing.

                                      In my suggestion I was looking at 50mm diameter for more torque but I see that the 4250/06 800kV that I've bought to go in my Swordsman 33 produces 980w so a pair of them could be a good choice. I tend to use Overlander but Leopard and Turnigy are good as well.

                                      I see that the spec. for those you are thinking of is 3100w (yikes!) and they are recommended for race boats. I refer to Paul's post!

                                      Chris

                                      Edited By Chris Fellows on 03/05/2020 11:11:12

                                      #87498
                                      Chris Fellows
                                      Participant
                                        @chrisfellows72943

                                        Photo attached of my big Huntsman. Not going too bad considering that's its fitted with a single MFA850 brushed motor and a brick of a lead acid battery. Battery and ESC have already gone down the tip and will be followed by the motor in due course!

                                        Given the performance with that rubbish in it shows that it's not going to take much more to give it the spritely performance that it deserves and Dave demands!

                                        Chris

                                        picture4.jpg

                                        #87500
                                        Ray Wood 3
                                        Participant
                                          @raywood3

                                          Hi Chris

                                          Never throw a motor away, it will be ideal when you build a tug boat 😀

                                          Regards Ray

                                          #87503
                                          gecon
                                          Participant
                                            @gecon

                                            Joe said it was a Huntsman 47"….or have I missed something? -as usual.

                                            George

                                            #87508
                                            Joe Beckett
                                            Participant
                                              @joebeckett71895

                                              Thanks all for the info and advice and thanks Chris for the picture, I hope mine will look like this when done. I've joined MBM but need to wait to look at UKMike's build, thanks for the pointer though. As regards the motor question, following all the input, I've scaled down my ideas (forgot I wasn't building an Apollo rocket!) and have seen this set up:

                                              **LINK**

                                              **LINK**

                                              Running on 1x3S LiPo per motor. This seems to be a good compromise but may well change depending on the advice given!

                                              Oh, by the way…

                                              Anything is possible given limitless money and a will to meet your maker early!laugh

                                              #87509
                                              Dave Milbourn
                                              Participant
                                                @davemilbourn48782
                                                Posted by Ray Wood 2 on 03/05/2020 12:41:44:

                                                Hi Chris

                                                Never throw a motor away, it will be ideal when you build a tug boat 😀

                                                Regards Ray

                                                I can't find a tug in the Big Book of Faireys, Ray. I'd use that motor as a doorstop, a workshop weight or something to stop the wind from blowing off the dustbin lid…..

                                                George
                                                It is a 47" Huntsman, but digression is almost de rigueur on this forum. Do keep up, old chap! wink

                                                Dave M

                                                #87510
                                                ashley needham
                                                Participant
                                                  @ashleyneedham69188

                                                  There is some serious over estimating going on here.

                                                  Chris has posted a nice picture of a boat going reasonably well on an 850 motor (120watts, ish?) and a big SLA. I know it would go a lot better with a Nimh pack, and even more betterer with. Lipo, on the orig motor.

                                                  All this talk of 900W motors….?

                                                  Ashley

                                                  #87514
                                                  Chris Fellows
                                                  Participant
                                                    @chrisfellows72943

                                                    Good job that Harry's not contributing! smiley

                                                    Dave has read my mind! I'm already building a slow Fairey with an even slower one in the wings.

                                                    Joe – I don't think you have to be a member to read posts?

                                                    Chris

                                                    #87517
                                                    Dave Milbourn
                                                    Participant
                                                      @davemilbourn48782
                                                      Posted by ashley needham on 03/05/2020 13:56:39:

                                                      There is some serious over estimating going on here.

                                                      Chris has posted a nice picture of a boat going reasonably well on an 850 motor (120watts, ish?) and a big SLA. I know it would go a lot better with a Nimh pack, and even more betterer with. Lipo, on the orig motor.

                                                      All this talk of 900W motors….?

                                                      Ashley

                                                      Ashley

                                                      There's no avoiding the fact that the very first big Huntsman 31 had a powerful 10cc glowplug motor installed; 1.2BHP is around 900W. There's no estimation involved there, m'duck.

                                                      Dave M

                                                    Viewing 25 posts - 1 through 25 (of 41 total)
                                                    • Please log in to reply to this topic. Registering is free and easy using the links on the menu at the top of this page.

                                                    Code of conduct | Forum Help/FAQs

                                                    Advert

                                                    Latest Replies

                                                    Home Forums Beginners Topics

                                                    Viewing 25 topics - 1 through 25 (of 25 total)
                                                    Viewing 25 topics - 1 through 25 (of 25 total)

                                                    View full reply list.

                                                    Advert

                                                    Newsletter Sign-up