Andrew
With a prop of that size and number of blades I'd consider direct drive. It's a lot quieter! One of these motors on 12v will give you plenty of power at a budget price **LINK**
If you really want a geared motor then the same supplier stocks the MFA geared 500 type, but the 6:1 ratio unit generally recommended for 12v may be a little on the slow side for a 42mm prop. BTW I have a friend who is selling two new Decaperms @ £100 for the pair, but they're the 6v version. I gather the new price is £148 each!
Dave M