freeship2,6

Advert

freeship2,6

Home Forums Scratch build freeship2,6

  • This topic is empty.
Viewing 21 posts - 1 through 21 (of 21 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #19598
    neil hp
    Participant
      @neilhp
      hi Paul, ,suppose all I have is the loa and beam of a ship, but plenty of good quality photos, can lines be obtained.
      my reason for asking is that I have spent the best part of 10 years looking for plans on and off of the 1913 built King Orry 3 without any results.
      I believe that there is a builders model of her in the Isle Of Man somewhere but repeated requests from different places has produced nothing.
      Then about 2 years ago I found a stunning book all about the ship, with plenty of photos, but still no plans.
      Can a set be produced from photos or is it a basic imposibility.
      cheers,neil.
      Advert
      #6549
      neil hp
      Participant
        @neilhp

        Plans from Photos.

        #19599
        Paul T
        Participant
          @pault84577
          Neil
           
          The model will be in the Steam Packet office at the Sea Terminal Building, Douglas.
          Can you email the photos to me?
           
          Paul
          #19600
          neil hp
          Participant
            @neilhp
            no, paul
            it’s not there, or in the Ramsey museum. i’ve tried and they don’t know where it is.
            someone told me that it was in Peel castle museum but i’ve emailed them twice and never recieved a reply.
            all the photos are in the book i have, so will scan them over the next day or so and then send to you, could you pm me please with your email address.
            by the way, i haven’t forgotten about that kit of the old steam driven Duke of Northumberland . i have been searching high and low but can’t locate it at the moment, gawd knows where it is. neil.
            #19601
            Paul T
            Participant
              @pault84577
              Hi Neil
               
              PM sent and Ive rung Dr John who lives on on the rock and he will have a look around this week.
               
              Paul
              #19602
              neil hp
              Participant
                @neilhp
                thanks for that paul,,
                and cheers to Dr John for any help you may be able to give me in tracking down the model of King Orry 111.
                back to my earlier post now,
                eurika.
                i had a brain storm whilst watching Ice Station Zebra, and went out to a box file i keep for old papers.
                right at the bottom was the pamphlet i was looking for, paul
                it was a company called PMS  [period model shipwrights] and was run by a gent called Richard Jewitt’
                in the pamphlet were a number of lifeboat hulls, the SS Shieldhall and the 3/4″ to the foot semi kit of the steam lifeboat DUKE OF NORTHUMBERLAND.
                The kit included 12v pumps for propulsion and some fittings and hull.
                he was based in Gosport  AND Grenoble in france.
                did anyone buy a kit and build, or does anyone know if the chap is still around
                the pamphlet is so old it doesn’t have a 1 in the phone no.
                neil,the pamphlet is dated jan 1992, and in those days the semi kit was priced at £210.00p, so not cheap.

                Edited By neil howard-pritchard on 21/03/2009 20:53:19

                #19603
                Bob Abell 2
                Participant
                  @bobabell2
                  Hello NEIL
                   
                  Last year at the Birchwood show, there was a working model of the Duke of Northumberland and it was made by a Mr Jones of Holyhead and I think he can be reached via the Holyhead Maritime museum.
                   
                  If this is of any use?
                   
                  Bob
                  #19604
                  neil hp
                  Participant
                    @neilhp
                    cheers bob.
                    sadly i have tried numerous times to engage in conversation with him about the drive system of his boat, both on mayhem sight and at a couple of shows, [ including southport lifeboat show ] and he is more than reluctant to share his knowledge of how he made it work.
                    none committal is the nicest way of putting it.
                    and for once in my life i’m trying to be tactfull
                    i think it’s the same boat as i’ve only ever seen the one.a medal winner at the ME exhibition it is built at 1;12 scale.
                    neil.

                    Edited By neil howard-pritchard on 21/03/2009 21:00:11

                    #19606
                    Keith Richardson
                    Participant
                      @keithrichardson77867
                      Hello Neil.
                      Re creating a set of plans from just photographs.
                      That is what I did using Delftship then Freeship (both have the same origin, but you now have to pay for delftship).
                      The first decision to be made is chine or non-chine – I did this from studying many photographs, the best being ones where the boats had been pulled up onto the mud, propped up with poles, and workers scraping off the seaweed etc that fouls the hulls, and adding their mixture of hot animal fat mixed with lime to control the Toredo wood ship worm. This is why they look white below the waterline. I chose non-chine.
                      Then you need to indicate how many stations you will need – I chose 20 so that I could control the overall shape to keep it ‘true’. I forget the technical term (sorry) but the program provides you with a few “major” control lines that you push and squeeze to the shape you want, so that the cross-sections are approximately what you want (as you define from studying the photos). The side view allows you to adjust the sheerlines, deck location, rake of stern and bow etc (again guided by photos). The plan view (top view) allows you to nudge the beam towards the length-width ratio photos tell you it should be, the location of maximum beam, the shapes of the bows and transom or pointed or rounded stern. Moving the major control lines is good because the other lines move in response to the changes you are deliberately making. Be aware that you are working in a 3D environment, so should frequently check the other views to see that what you are doing is what you want to have happen!
                      Gaining symmetry is not a problem as you are really only working on half of the model, the other portion being produced as a mirror image (this is only a nuisance when you are designing asymmetric catamaran hulls.)
                      I used the 3D program mainly for creating the complex-curve portions, leaving such aspects as superstructure etc till later on, once I had created full-model size plans.
                      One difficulty I experienced (and this may have stemmed from lack of understanding of this aspect of the FreeShip program) was that it produced a bitmapped image of the complete plan (side view, forard and aft hull section halves, plan half) to a certain size that was not at the full-size I wanted for my model. The problem with this is that when enlarged each of the linesbecome jagged and blocky and thick. My solution was to import the image into a program that could do vector drawing (such as Photoshop). The big advantage of this is that the lines are mathematical so enlarging considerably still produces thin accurate curved and straight lines.
                      Hope that goes some way to providing an answer to the question “Can you produce a set of accurate plans from just photographs?”
                      Cheers, Keith.
                       
                      #19612
                      Bob Abell 2
                      Participant
                        @bobabell2
                        Hello Neil
                         
                        Found a picture of the aforesaid model
                         
                        Bob

                        #19614
                        neil hp
                        Participant
                          @neilhp
                          Thanks keith, for the info.
                          For an idiot that has great difficulty in understanding most things, computor wise, I actually understood a lot of what you said until you spoke of Photoshop, but I have a friend who knows all about this so will comandere him to explain further. Many thanks.
                          Bob,
                          thanks for the photo, that’s the one. there was I think a short article in one of the modelling mags about the boat, It has won a few trophies, and is truly lovely to look at.
                          Just wish the guy would be more forthcoming and share his knowledge with other modellers, but sadly he seams very reluctant to do so.
                          Paul, will start down loading some photos this evening and will send them to you later tonight.
                          Many thanks to you all.
                          I might get to build my King Orry after all. cheers,neil.
                          #19620
                          JC Uknz 1
                          Participant
                            @jcuknz1
                            If you have a crude drawing which ‘jags’ when enlarged one solution is to get the editing programme to ‘re-sample’ or ‘interpolate’ using a greater number of ‘dots per inch’ [ oir cm ]    This is possible with any of the better editing programmes, my choice is Paint Shop Pro and any version from v.7 onwards will do it for you, maybe earlier versions too.
                             
                            But I wonder why a ‘jagged drawing is any less useful than a non-jogged drawing because surely it is simple enough to add a line to follow the medium of the jags.  One can get pre-occupied with ‘irrelevant detail’ at times when millimetre here or there is on no consequence.     When I found the kit I had bought was too small for my purposes I put the components on my scanner and doubled the size which resulted in some give and take when building.
                            #19622
                            Keith Richardson
                            Participant
                              @keithrichardson77867
                              Hi JC Uknz.
                              You suggested: “If you have a crude drawing which ‘jags’ when enlarged one solution is to get the editing programme to ‘re-sample’ or ‘interpolate’ using a greater number of ‘dots per inch’ [ oir cm ]    This is possible with any of the better editing programmes, my choice is Paint Shop Pro and any version from v.7 onwards will do it for you, maybe earlier versions too.”
                              An excellent idea, but I did try that and was amazed at the extent of the change produced by the procedure. What happened was that before enlarging I had created the mirror half of each bulkhead, so that they were then perfectly symmetrical. I then enlarged as you suggest, and it looked fine until I folded the printout for the bulkheads along the centreline to check symmetry, and was dismayed to see how different each half had become. They were now quite asymmetrical. I can’t give you a measurement as I destroyed the results and started again, but it was considerable.
                              However, by working with vector lines, the positioning of the lines is exact so enlargement did not destroy symmetry (because the dot positions are determined mathematically by the program). For the 3D lines of a hull to prove “true” where the water flow will be as best as possible, I think it is worth worrying.
                              However, perhaps I am being too fussy, because my building procedure, once the plans have been created, is far from fine and accurate!
                              Cheers, Keith

                              Edited By Keith Richardson on 22/03/2009 23:19:04

                              #19623
                              ARH
                              Participant
                                @arh
                                Niel said, Just wish the guy would be more forthcoming and share his knowledge with other modellers, but sadly he seams very reluctant to do so.
                                 
                                Thats very unusual for Les, normally you can not stop him talking.
                                #19630
                                neil hp
                                Participant
                                  @neilhp
                                  ARH,
                                  perhaps you could ask him to contact me via model boats forum.
                                  I built a plug for the D of N many years ago and then ditched it because I couldn’t (because I’m NO engineer) design a drive system to “steam ” the boat.
                                  However, my interests for the model come from the fact that my grandad gave me some Blueprints( yes they actually were blueprint ) of the lifeboat drive pumps, as he had    asan apprentice pattern maker back in the 1880’s worked on the patterns for the pumps of the boat.(sadly these have long since been lost) and those plans clearly showed side propulsion nozzles for pushing the lifeboat away from the casualty sideways,not just fore and aft.
                                  I would love to see his set up of pumps and such as I would like to build one of her myself, but as I say he was never willing to “lift the lid” and show me her workings.
                                  Neil.
                                  #19631
                                  ARH
                                  Participant
                                    @arh
                                    Try his e-mail.
                                     
                                     
                                    #19632
                                    Bob Abell 2
                                    Participant
                                      @bobabell2
                                      Hello Chaps
                                       
                                      Last year, Les Jones came to our club and gave us a nice  lecture on his models and model boat construction, unfortuneately I was away at the time and couldn`t attend.
                                       
                                      He brought his model masterpieces with him, for all to examine
                                       
                                       
                                      Just thought I`d mention it…….Bob
                                      #19633
                                      Bob Abell 2
                                      Participant
                                        @bobabell2
                                        Just found this picture of the models in the Holyhead Maritime Museum

                                        #19637
                                        neil hp
                                        Participant
                                          @neilhp

                                          Cheers, ARH, Will do. neil.

                                          #19675
                                          JC Uknz 1
                                          Participant
                                            @jcuknz1
                                            Keith ….. When a computer stuffs up the answer is to get it right with half the boat and then to make a mirror image.  This is easy with the better editing programme that I have as a photographer where you have layers, though actually I know I could do it with my very basic MS ‘Paint’ programme which I use for simple jobs.   If you have half of the drawing you can copy it, paste it back, flip the copy horizontally and then being careful not to ‘click’ anything move it into register with the original …. naturally you have to first increase the ‘canvas size’ to accomodate the double drawing.
                                             
                                            Sorry you had trouble but there is usually a way around things.
                                             
                                            When I’m scaling up from drawings in an old book, bound copies of Model Boats or Model Maker, I usually find that half the lines are drawn from the middle station forwards and along side them half towards the stern … so this mirroring is an essential part of the process.
                                             
                                            I know I use vector layers when adding letters but I havn’t a glue what they are

                                            Edited By JC Uknz on 24/03/2009 04:15:15

                                            #19726
                                            Keith Richardson
                                            Participant
                                              @keithrichardson77867
                                              Hi JC Uknz.
                                              My problem with combining enlargement of a bit image (made of many pixels of colours) with then mirroring the result, is that even though the final bulkheads will be symmetrical, they may not be “correct” when compared with one another along the hull, and so result in bumps and hollows that would result in the hull lines running ‘not true’.
                                              Using vector drawing guarantees accuracy through the enlargement process.
                                              Do you use Photoshop? If so, I would be happy to offer a few pointers for using the vector drawing aspect of the program.
                                              Regards, Keith

                                              Edited By Keith Richardson on 25/03/2009 00:55:48

                                            Viewing 21 posts - 1 through 21 (of 21 total)
                                            • Please log in to reply to this topic. Registering is free and easy using the links on the menu at the top of this page.

                                            Code of conduct | Forum Help/FAQs

                                            Advert

                                            Latest Replies

                                            Home Forums Scratch build Topics

                                            Viewing 25 topics - 1 through 25 (of 25 total)
                                            Viewing 25 topics - 1 through 25 (of 25 total)

                                            View full reply list.

                                            Advert

                                            Newsletter Sign-up