Hi Alan. On larger water guage cocks we used “Brasso metal polish”, however make sure you have not managed to get a ‘step’ on your valve. When lapping it is easy to leave a ridge at the end of valve, (at the thick end on the plug/core, or the thin end of the body) this stops the core fitting snug, and further lapping dosn;t always remove the step.
Hope this helps Happy New Year Tom