How do I calculate the keel weight for the model Star 45 I’m building?

Advert

How do I calculate the keel weight for the model Star 45 I’m building?

Home Forums Beginners How do I calculate the keel weight for the model Star 45 I’m building?

  • This topic is empty.
Viewing 18 posts - 1 through 18 (of 18 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #73647
    Samuel Crowe
    Participant
      @samuelcrowe16582

      Hi model sailors,

      I'm building my first model boat, a Star 45 with a Braine steering system. However I have no idea how to choose what weight my boat's keel should have. I can post photos if requested.

      Advert
      #2725
      Samuel Crowe
      Participant
        @samuelcrowe16582

        I’m building my first model boat, a Star 45 with a braine steering system. However I have no idea how to choose what weight my boat’s keel should have.

        #73649
        Colin Bishop
        Moderator
          @colinbishop34627

          We don't seem to have many yachties on this Forum but there is a lot of online information about Star 45s such as this site: **LINK**

          Just Google Star 45 model yacht and you will get lots of hits.

          Colinj

          #73651
          Malcolm Frary
          Participant
            @malcolmfrary95515

            From https://www.theamya.org/boats/star45/Star45_Rules.pdf rule 1.10 says that there is no maximum weight, but the minimum weight is 12 pounds ready to sail (OK its a radio yacht, but the numbers will be close). Once you have an idea what it weighs without the bulb, you know what is needed as a minimum, the maximum is that which does not either sink it or break the fin. More weight will let it handle more wind with the same sails, but due to it sitting lower and getting more hull drag, it will need more wind.

            I hope that the chosen pool is access-friendly. Braine boats are fascinating (i.e. tricky) to set up. Predicting where they are going, and how fast, is a real art. Experience says that a self steering yacht will only steer straight when it knows that it has a short sail but you have the longest possible run to get there first. One of the reasons that I put radios in mine.

            #73666
            Samuel Crowe
            Participant
              @samuelcrowe16582

              Thanks for the replies!

              I have tried to google it, but it seems there is no basic ratio of ringing to keel bulb weight.

              Malcolm Fray, your post was particularly helpful. but 12 pounds minimum? That's 192 oz, heavy! I intend to use a lead fishing weight (due to perfect shape) for a keel bulb. Perhaps I should just try out different weights for a medium to light wind. I have some experience with braine steering, it just seems so much more work, expense and difficulty to put batteries and a servo in it.

              Edited By Samuel Crowe on 16/10/2017 23:53:12

              Edited By Samuel Crowe on 16/10/2017 23:53:37

              #73676
              Paul T
              Participant
                @pault84577

                Hello Samuel

                This document from across the pond might help Link you will find that our american cousins are quite exacting regarding the specifications of this particular sailing model including, as Malcolm pointed out, a minimum weight requirement of 12lbs (5443.11g)

                Paul

                #73678
                Ray Wood 3
                Participant
                  @raywood3

                  Hi Samuel

                  I'd estimate 7-8lbs seems average for a 50"Marblehead, the Star is not much shorter but being single chine has a fair beam/displacement. You can take some weight off the lead bulb if she comes out over weight or too deep in the water.

                  Regards Ray

                  #73703
                  Samuel Crowe
                  Participant
                    @samuelcrowe16582

                    Hello,

                    Thanks again for the fast replies!

                    I understand the American weight requirement, however as I was using rough plans, I did not scale my boat properly (it is my first ever). I've figured out that since the length of the proper Star 45's is 45 inches, and my hull is 28 inches long its a multiple of roughly 1.6. So since the keel bulb minimum weight is 12 pounds, 12 divided by 1.6 = 7.5 pounds for my boat. That is still very heavy and about $8 British pounds worth of lead. It just feels like the boat needs something smaller. Any other thoughts?

                    Sincerely, Samuel

                    #73704
                    Malcolm Frary
                    Participant
                      @malcolmfrary95515
                      Posted by Samuel Crowe on 18/10/2017 02:01:13:

                      Hello,

                      Thanks again for the fast replies!

                      I understand the American weight requirement, however as I was using rough plans, I did not scale my boat properly (it is my first ever). I've figured out that since the length of the proper Star 45's is 45 inches, and my hull is 28 inches long its a multiple of roughly 1.6. So since the keel bulb minimum weight is 12 pounds, 12 divided by 1.6 = 7.5 pounds for my boat. That is still very heavy and about $8 British pounds worth of lead. It just feels like the boat needs something smaller. Any other thoughts?

                      Sincerely, Samuel

                      For the full size model according to the information in the link, it is not the bulb weight at minimum 12 pounds, that is the entire boat including the keel weight where 12 pounds is the minimum sailing weight. Since your model is about half the length, and when talking weight you are also talking volume, thats about 1/8th the weight. With a ballast ratio of about 50% you are in the 24 oz area total, so a keel weight of about 12oz, maybe 14oz. This fits well with the old Akela design (used to be a free plan years ago) that was 25" long and carried a 12oz weight as well as the modern 25 inch racers (DF65) which carry the same weight.

                      Shrunken yachts rarely perform up to expectations without there being some modification, usually a longer fin with the same weight to enable sailing in a wider range of conditions. The bulb does need to be a very good hydrodynamic shape, casual lumps cripple performance.

                      #73713
                      Samuel Crowe
                      Participant
                        @samuelcrowe16582

                        Hi,

                        You have my many thanks Malcolm. That has been one of the most useful replies so far. What you said before makes sense now. I'll look for something around the 10oz to 15oz range when I do the experimenting for the best keel weight. I'm feeling pretty excited, my boat is coming together nicely. You people that have been in the business far a while would probably cringe if you saw it, but its my first and I'm happy with it!

                        This forum has been massively helpful to me, my sincere thanks to all who contributed!

                        Samuel

                        #73714
                        Malcolm Frary
                        Participant
                          @malcolmfrary95515

                          Just looked at my Victoria. Its 30" long, weighs 5 lb and almost half that weight is the bulb. The draught is about 9" (waterline to bottom of weight, and it carries 400 square inches of sail on a 39" mast. While by no means the same boat, yours is somewhere between that and the old 25" Akela , now known as "XL25" with drawings and more information at http://www.sealevel.demon.nl/english/downloadsXL25modelyacht.htm

                          #73715
                          Telstar
                          Participant
                            @telstar

                            Hi Samuel

                            Try this site **LINK** It may offer more confusion dont know or maybe not. Success with your build

                            Cheers Tom

                            #73719
                            Tim Rowe
                            Participant
                              @timrowe83142

                              Hello Samuel
                              ​Lots of good information coming your way particularly around the scaling effect that does not work in your favour. Malcolm was certainly pointing you in the right direction and I am sure he won't mind me pointing out that when he described making the keel longer he really meant deeper. On a yacht, long keel has a meaning of its own and the important thing is to get the keel weight (and therefore the centre of gravity) as deep as possible.
                              ​As to the weight required on your model it is very easy to find out by practical testing in a bath. On the plan it will show the designed waterline and you can mark this on the hull. You now add weight making an allowance for mast, sails, fittings, radio, batteries etc and when the model is floating on that waterline you can measure the added weight and that is the amount of lead you have to add to the keel. The link from Telstar is a very useful way of getting the dimensions of a bulb shape that is the weight you want. Lead is not very strong so although a narrow shape creates less drag it will get bent easily if it overhangs the keel. A model yacht for just pottering about will be fine with something a bit stubbier.
                              ​Finally and due to the scale effect and not having to comply with any rule I would keep the depth of the keel only a bit less than the original and not in proportion. Remember, the wind doesn't know what size the boat is.
                              ​As to ways of casting the lead you will find lots of ideas (and precautions) on U Tube.

                              #73721
                              Ray Wood 3
                              Participant
                                @raywood3

                                Hi Samuel

                                I the quest for your keel weight for your Star 28 , you may consider Vic Smeeds Panache design 30" long has a keel weight built on the lower part of the fin with lead sheet flashing and interestingly for you he quotes 2 1/2lbs for RC and 3 1/4lbs for free sailing which fits the bill for you with your vane control, whilst googling I also found the plan in pdf format so I might have a go at building one Vic was and still is the Boss and gets my full respect.

                                Regards Ray

                                #73763
                                Andy Stoneman
                                Participant
                                  @andystoneman15177

                                  Hi Ray, what sort of keel weight do you have on your Thames sailing barge ? The barge I've recently built has a 3kg bulb weight but I'm thinking its not enough should the wind pickup, its a 1:24th scale. Also whats the depth of your fin/keel ? I took it for its first run the other day and was a bit disappointed on its performance, Most probably due to the lack of wind, 11klm/hr.

                                  Regards, Andy

                                  #73768
                                  Ray Wood 3
                                  Participant
                                    @raywood3

                                    Hi Andy

                                    My barge has a winged keel moulded in GRP with 6 1/2 lbs of lead poured into the wing, its about 9" deep, she sails better with it than the much deeper Marblehead fin keel, and is much easier to launch. It takes quite a lot of tuning of the rig to get competitive boat speed, I've been sailing Veronica for 3 seasons now and I'm just getting there, but I have more plans for next year. Make sure your hatches are sealed, they do tend to beat to windward with wet decks in a blow

                                    Regards Ray

                                    #73814
                                    Andy Stoneman
                                    Participant
                                      @andystoneman15177

                                      Hi Ray

                                      So i`m probably not too far from the correct weight of 3kg, the allup weight of my barge is 9.7kg the fin is a traditional keel shape with depth of 9-1/2" so I'm not too far from the right depth, Your winged keel looks interesting. My barge is scratch built and a lot of guessing from photo`s of other barges plus. More trials underway hopefully next week when the winds are more favourable.I liked your H.M.S. Diamond model, an old ship of mine.

                                      Regards, Andy

                                      #73819
                                      Ray Wood 3
                                      Participant
                                        @raywood3

                                        Hi Andy

                                        Not wanting to Hijack Samuels thread, I've started a Thames Sailing Barge thread in the Sailing section.

                                        Regards Ray

                                      Viewing 18 posts - 1 through 18 (of 18 total)
                                      • Please log in to reply to this topic. Registering is free and easy using the links on the menu at the top of this page.

                                      Code of conduct | Forum Help/FAQs

                                      Advert

                                      Latest Replies

                                      Home Forums Beginners Topics

                                      Viewing 25 topics - 1 through 25 (of 25 total)
                                      Viewing 25 topics - 1 through 25 (of 25 total)

                                      View full reply list.

                                      Advert

                                      Newsletter Sign-up